Report A Claim
Claims Reporting Company Directory
We are happy to assist you in any way possible with your claim, however, the following carriers have direct claim reporting services available. Prior to calling, please have your policy number and claim details available for the claims adjuster. Your insurance company will forward a copy of your claim report to our office. Also, we are here for you as well, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Stolly Insurance – 24 Hour Claims Reporting at 1-800-686-2147.
Companies that accept online or phone claims
Hastings Mutual Insurance Company
24 Hour Claims Reporting by phone or online.
800-442-8277
Motorist Mutual Insurance Company
24 Hour Claims Reporting by phone or online.
800-876-8766
Safeco Insurance
24 Hour Claims reporting by phone. Insured must call Safeco directly.
1-800-332-3226
State Auto Insurance Companies
24 Hour Claims Reporting by phone or online.
800-766-1853
Companies that accept phone claims only
Western Reserve Group
It is requested that the insured contact the agency during office hours if it is not an emergency.
800-362-0426
Ohio Casualty
24 Hour Claims Reporting by phone.
866-255-5530
Hanover
24 Hour Claims reporting by phone.
800-628-0250
Auto Owners Insurance
It is requested that the insured contact the agency during office hours if it is not an emergency.
888-252-4626
Ohio Fair Plan
The Ohio FAIR Plan Underwriting Association Claims Department will adjust the claims on behalf of the Ohio FAIR Plan (OFP). Notices of claim can be received in letter form, on ACORD Forms or by telephone, fax, or e-mail. Notification may come from the insurance agent, attorney, insured, or claimant. All correspondence is to be directed to:
Ohio FAIR Plan Claims Department
2500 Corporate Exchange Dr., Suite 250
Columbus, OH 43231
If the claim requires immediate attention, contact may be made by telephone. The phone numbers are 614-839-6446 or inside Ohio at 800-282-1772.
The Property Claim Form can be completed and forwarded via e/mail. Please complete the form as completely as possible. As mentioned above, if the claim requires immediate attention, please call the Claim Department.
Questions or concerns can be made via e-mail to claims@ohiofairplan.com
